Awesome doesn't begin to describe these songs.

There's a song I've been hooked on lately for no apparant reason. I don't know who sings it, but the main lyrics say "I want you to want me." I doubt that song would fit, but I suggested it just in case.

I am unsure as to how comic/serious this is, but "The Impression I get" would work for a more comedical piece while still being open for ACTIONABLE SCENES

Otherwise I'd definitely go with "So, long, Astoria". It does have meaningful lyrics, and is enjoyable.

The dreamer one or whatever is great and all but loses out to these two, in my opinion.

Well, now that I think about it, it would probably be a good idea to get a certain mister Yami to score us an original piece.